3 Comments
User's avatar
Frederick R Prete's avatar

This is a very good essay. Standardized tests can serve an important function but that is different than teaching the subjects, themselves. For instance see this article on the much-maligned ACT:

https://quillette.com/2022/07/16/the-act-discriminates/

my best, Frederick

Expand full comment
Tardigrade_Sonata's avatar

Good lord. To write even that McCarthy paragraph, you need to already understand that: A) "serpentine" is most commonly an adjective (and break that custom); B) directly after, break the rule against sentence fragments and dependent clauses (to suggest the choppiness and discontinuity of encountering a post-apocalyptic landscape); and C) know that most modern writers would opt for the adverb "entirely" rather than the more archaic or baroque "entire." It's hard for me to believe that educated, literate people think that a writer like McCarthy is working in some kind of mystical ignorance of grammar.

Expand full comment
Rebecca Birch's avatar

... or that markers wouldn't be able to tell the difference between stylistic features and grammatical errors. A conceit on a number of levels.

Expand full comment